The Tyranny of Self-Improvement

On January, greatness, and the hunger that never rests

“The great thing is not to accomplish, but to become.”
— Thomas Merton

Every January, the health clubs fill up.

Parking lots that sat half-empty in November suddenly require strategy. Ellipticals that had been quietly preparing for retirement are wiped down with missionary zeal. Everyone is drinking green liquids that look like lawn clippings and cost twelve dollars, because suffering is more credible when it’s expensive.

The health food stores run out of kale.

No one actually likes kale. No one has ever said, after a long and demoralizing day, You know what would heal me right now? Aggressive bitterness. And yet every January, kale becomes sacramental. Proof that we are serious. A leafy receipt for the vow we are renewing with ourselves.

New year.
New you.

Or at least a more disciplined, socially acceptable draft of you.

January does not invent our dissatisfaction. It simply schedules it. It tells us the problem is not that life is fragile, unfair, and finite, but that we have failed to optimize it. With the right plan, the right products, the right grit, we could finally become someone worthy of our own existence.

So we make lists.

Lose weight.
Build muscle.
Get focused.
Read smarter books.
Consume better content.
Become the kind of person who wakes up early and feels good about it.

These lists are rarely gentle. They behave more like compliance officers. They audit our snacks. They monitor our rest. They file reports when we sit still too long without producing anything measurable.

Some people talk about an inner critic. Many of us operate under a full regulatory agency.

Highly credentialed.
Endlessly reviewing.
Never impressed.

What’s remarkable is not how harsh these voices are, but how respectable they sound. They speak fluent productivity. They quote wellness studies. They use words like potential and discipline and maximizing your life, which is a strange phrase when you think about it, given that life eventually ends no matter how well-managed the calendar is.

These voices are familiar because we were trained by them.

Parents. Schools. Churches. Workplaces. Platforms.
A thousand systems gently insisting that love is conditional, rest is suspicious, and stillness must be justified.

I noticed this most clearly at an awards ceremony.

It was legitimate. Prestigious. A room full of applause that sounded expensive. One by one, people stood while their accomplishments were read aloud. Books written. Organizations founded. Influence scaled. Each biography felt like a résumé read at gunpoint.

Somewhere in the middle of it all, something shifted. Gratitude gave way to inventory. My body knew before my mind did. I folded inward. Shrunk. What was meant to say you belong here quietly translated into you should probably be doing more.

No one said this out loud.
The system didn’t need to.
I had already internalized the metrics.

That moment isn’t unusual. It’s the norm.

Grief taught me this first. There are forces in the world that cannot be defeated by force without costing us our own interior ground.

We celebrate people by proving their usefulness. We praise children for performance. We reward adults for endurance. We admire leaders for domination and call it strength. Then we act surprised when no one knows how to rest without guilt.

What we are really measuring in these moments is not excellence.
It’s permission.

Permission to stop.
Permission to be ordinary.

This is where self-improvement becomes tyrannical.

Not because growth is wrong. But because improvement quietly replaces love. It becomes a way to manage fear. If we are better, faster, leaner, smarter, maybe we won’t have to feel the unease underneath everything. Maybe we can outrun uncertainty. Maybe we can earn safety.

It’s fear wearing a planner.

We recognize this logic easily when it shows up on a world stage. Tyrants never announce themselves as tyrants. They speak of greatness. Of winning. Of being unmatched. They confuse conquest with meaning and call the damage necessary.

It is much harder to recognize the same logic when it lives inside us. When it speaks in our own voice. When we make our lists sincerely, and still feel vaguely accused.

This is the private version of hollow greatness.
The voice that says more where enough once lived.
Better where mercy once softened the edges.
Next where wisdom might have known when to stop.

You can gain the world this way.
Platforms. Praise. Possessions.
And still lose the quiet center where the soul knows when it has enough.

Thomas Merton warned that we spend our lives climbing ladders leaning against the wrong wall. Not because climbing is immoral, but because motion feels safer than meaning. If we keep moving, we don’t have to ask where we’re going.

Improvement is not the enemy.
But improvement without acceptance becomes a form of violence.

If there is such a thing as real greatness, it is likely unimpressive.

It does not dominate.
It does not scale well.
It does not perform for strangers.

It knows when to stop climbing.
It knows how to sit down without collapsing.
It knows how to stay.

Maybe January does not need another list.

Maybe it needs an interruption.

A body leaning back instead of bracing.
A freezer door opened without convening a tribunal.
An award resting on a shelf, no longer proving anything, just collecting dust.

Not all hunger means we need more.

Some hungers are warnings. Signals that we have mistaken striving for life, improvement for love, and exhaustion for virtue.

That may be the most revealing thing about human nature: we will submit to almost any tyranny if it promises belonging. We will exhaust ourselves trying to earn what should never have been conditional. We will call it discipline because that sounds nobler than fear.

We are not formed by our ideals.
We are formed by what withholds rest.

So long as improvement stands in for love, we will keep mistaking motion for meaning.

The quiet revolution is not self-optimization.
It is permission.

Permission to stop without collapsing.
To be unfinished without panic.
To live a life that does not need to justify itself.

That may be what real greatness looks like.
Unscalable. Unimpressive.
And finally, free.

If you want to think more slowly, you’re welcome here. Subscribe for the next one. If it lingered, tap the heart or pass it along.